Guns of Icarus – A Review of an Indie Game’s Steampunk Promise

Guns of Icarus – A Review of an Indie Game’s Steampunk Promise
3.5

Platforms:

Browser, PC, iOS

Game Name:

Guns of Icarus

Publisher(s):

Steam

Developer(s):

Muse Games

Genre(s):

Steampunk Shooter

Release Date:

November 04, 2009

ESRB Rating:

Rating Pending

Is Steampunk Just A Skin?

I recently shared a debate with a friend who argued that a short film called The Anachronism was not Steampunk solely based on the fact that two children discover a mechanical squid washed up on the beach. I countered that this Jules Verne inspired bit of tech could be nothing other than Steampunk in its truest form to which his rebuttal was that Verne predates Steampunk by a century.

At the crux of the argument was the question of whether or not Steampunk is merely an aesthetic or some sort of new canon unto itself? I would argue that it is a term created by Steve Jackson, creator of the GURPS paper and dice system to encapsulate many sources that include everything from Jules Verne to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to Mary Shelley all the way to the wild west robots of Westworld (and its iteration the 1998 film starring Will Smith “Wild Wild West“), Neil Gaiman’s “Stardust” or most of Terry Gilliam’s catalog.

steampunk sky-pirate zeppelin from Stardust
A steampunk sky-pirate zeppelin from the film "Stardust"

Lest I digress into a protracted thesis on the etymology of Steampunk, I will retrain my opening to underline the fact that many games have drawn upon the Steampunk aesthetic to hype their wares, but very few (including Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura, Myst, Rise of Nations: Rise of Legends, and the Thief franchise) have delivered on their promise to immerse us in its wonders. Many dip their toe in those waters (Warcraft, Final Fantasy, Cogs, Glim) but only in a very superficial way, not in a way that requires the underlying concept of anachronism in order to unfold.

Then we arrive at Guns of Icarus from Muse Games.

Built on the Unity engine that allows 3D gameplay inside a browser, and beloved by indie game developers, Guns of Icarus made its journey to PC gaming from browser-based origins before arriving at Steam as an $8 download.

Premise / Promise

The game draws on some of the most beloved iconography of the Steampunk lexicon by positioning the player in the shoes of a swarthy zeppelin pilot hellbent on delivering cargo while warding off vicious Sky Pirates who threaten to pillage, plunder and destroy his vessel.

Gameplay

Gameplay consists of running from one of six gun positions to blast the looters’ biplanes out of the sky all the while running to and fro to make repairs on damaged engines, rigs, cargo holds and the zeppelin itself. One level to the next varies only in the number of incoming attackers, increasing the need to manage one’s position on the ship in order to ensure that nothing gets too far out out control to restore things to their proper balance.

All very promising – a word I may use more than once in the scope of this review.

I must point out that as a free browser game, this is unquestionably a fantastic offering; challenging and immersive gameplay that consists of managing priorities so as to arrive safely at the drop off location intact while offering rich graphics and audio to boot.

One might assume then, that as a port to the PC, the rich canvas would be embellished, that Campaign modes would mean storylines added, richer, more varied gameplay introduced, graphics capabilities optimized and exploited. What we get, however, are additional gun choices, some weather patterns, 4 person multi-player mode and some other minor, but ultimately inconsequential additions.

Guns of Icarus from Muse Games - a steampunk indie shooter

What I would love to have seen is not too much to ask (and I put it this way in hopes the developers will consider it still in a future update) might include a backstory, perhaps even a cut scene to give this setting some context and illusion of motive, improved backgrounds: with a wonderful setting like cloud-based naval battles, the opportunity for lush panoramic skies is almost a requirement as opposed to the low resolution pixelated background wallpaper that tears at highest resolution, and variety in enemy models. These are not even gameplay requests, per se, but expectations for a title that asks us to make the leap from free to eight bucks.

There are five gauges at the bottom right of the HUD display at what level a given section of the ship may require your attention. Unfortunately the gauges are not labelled and so they aren’t very useful in aiding your strategy. This is an example for where Steampunk’s typically fastidious habit of labeling and annotating could easily be added without breaking suspension of disbelief, all the while making the gameplay more engaging.

Similarly, when the opportunity to add new guns to the armory is offered in between stages, there is no description of the various guns’ capabilities – this information is only displayed during the actual gameplay when the player approaches the weapon. The game would be far more Steampunkesque if these details were surrendered frequently and at the correct timing, contributing greatly to the feeling that we are in its dimension.

Multi-player mode understandably makes the game more enjoyable, primarily because it is a nightmare to handle both the gunner and maintenance duties alone. Certainly, switch hitting is part of the challenge, but coordinating with a buddy ups the fun factor.  Using the Steam framework for voice chat offers a provisional enhancement, but it isn’t ideal and with the lack of variety from level to level, makes the party a short one at best.

An Appeal to the Devs

I like your game, don’t get me wrong.  It was fun for a round or two.  But I really wanted to love it. So here are some suggestions for the update I hope you will release for the PC version (because as a purchasable title, this feels underdeveloped)

  • Please add variety to the objectives in the campaigns, even just for some minor variation
  • Please add labels to the gauges in the HUD
  • Please let us see weapon info at the point at which we are deciding what weapons to add
  • Please make the skies worth looking at
  • Please make the enemy models interesting and various, create fictional factions, give them names, alter their specs for strategic variation
  • Please add some narrative and full of mystery and intrigue because that is at the heart of a good Steampunk adventure
  • Please consider some other interesting spec upgrades for a job well done (purchaseable with money earned from delivering cargo) – weapon stabilizers, increased ship armor, alchemical enhancements, etc.

The fact of the matter is these are not problems with the fundamental gameplay which Guns of Icarus has managed to pull off, but rather the opportunities that have been missed by invoking the promise of the Steampunk universe to which we want to be transported and could be so easily implemented. Otherwise this is just a three-dimensional version of Space Invaders or Burger Time.

It isn’t the value or the eight bucks I am concerned with, it’s the lost opportunity to take a good game and make it really good, possibly even great.

Guns of Icarus is available on the iTunes App Store and Steam.

Rating: ★★★½☆ 

Indie-Game-Freak

[Los Angeles] The Indie Game Freak eats games for breakfast. It is a horror to behold, but it's good for the ecosystem.

5 thoughts on “Guns of Icarus – A Review of an Indie Game’s Steampunk Promise

  1. The term predates Steve Jackson’s usage by many years and was initially used mockingly as a play on the term cyberpunk, which was popular at the time, by a number of authors of alternate history novels. Novels that in fact often didn’t include any of the visual elements typically associated with the genre. I’d highly recommend any of the works of Tim Powers. I argue that it is both an aesthetic and canon, it’s the context that’s important.

    1. You are correct, credit should be given to K. W. Jeter who used it in reference for the works of Tim Powers, but perhaps even this is unprovable. Regardless, I would argue that Jackson’s company publishing a two-volume guide to the world of Steampunk (in fact the author of these books was William H. Stoddard under the Jackson banner) that included detailed outlines of the “rules” of a Steampunk universe drawing from Verne to HG Welles, Charles Babbage and Nikola Tesla and so on, cemented it as a genre.

      I am well aware that Steampunk is the progeny of the term Cyberpunk.

      Thanks for keeping the discussion lively!

  2. I had no idea it was attributed to K.W. Jeter. That’s interesting. Correct me if I’m wrong, but wasn’t GURPS Steampunk published in 2000 or 2001? Nearly two decades after the term was coined and long after many of the genres seminal works were written. While I’m sure it’s an interesting read (I’d love to get hold of a copy myself), it is strictly his interpretation of the genre and by no means a definitive work.

    You seem a fan of the genre yourself. I recommend you try and find a copy of Robot Carnival. It’s an old anime anthology movie circa the mid 80’s. It was only released in North America in VHS and is out of print everywhere, but some of the shorts are the most amazing examples of the genre I’ve seen.

  3. In fact, I had written a Steampunk novel before I had ever heard the term. In fact it was an editor of my book who pointed out that they loved all my Steampunk imagery, and I was gobsmacked – “Oh, you mean it has a name? It’s a genre?”

    I grew up on Tom Swift, Conan Doyle and Robert E. Howard novels, I also remember Lin Carter’s “Sky Pirates of Callisto” having a huge impact on me – and that featured steam powered Zeppelins in a book published by Dell in 1974! Mervyn Peake’s Gormenghast trilogy. Rube Goldberg comics, Fritz Lang’s Metropolis, Gilliam’s Time Bandits, Oz’s The Dark Crystal and later Jeunet’s Delicatessen, City of Lost Children. I know all about Robot Carnival, Ghibli, etc.

    I have read Gibson/Sterling’s “The Difference Engine”, played through Arcanum with all the mods, and even thrown Steampunk costume parties.

    So yeah, I would consider myself a fan of the genre.

    Yes GURPS Steampunk was published in 2000, but I maintain that it formed a sort of definitive composite of the many sources, details and feeling of the genre. Until I saw that, I really still felt like it was a moving target. GURPS screwed it into the brass tiling with rusty copper rivets.

Leave a Reply